THE TAKE
"Caleb Williams already better than Jordan Love. How about that? I'm sorry, but it's true. Jordan Love has played the majority of two seasons. Both of those seasons, double-digit interceptions. Here's the thing about Jordan Love, guy had 11 interceptions both years that he played. Caleb Williams played 17 games last year, had six. Caleb Williams's offensive coordinator was fired nine games into his rookie year with the worst offensive line in the league. And they fired his head coach three weeks after they fired his offensive coordinator because head coach didn't know that he could call timeouts."
BOLDNESS
62/100
GRADE
20/100
PLAYERS / TEAMS
Caleb WilliamsJordan Love
GRADING CRITERIA
TRUE IF
Caleb Williams finishes the 2025 NFL season with a lower interception total and/or higher passer rating than Jordan Love, or if Williams demonstrates statistically superior overall performance (QB rating, TD:INT ratio, completion percentage) across the season. Take is
FALSE IF
Jordan Love outperforms Williams across the majority of key passing efficiency metrics in 2025.
hot takerecency biascontrarianbold call
OUTCOME
CONFIRMED FALSEIn the 2025 NFL season, Jordan Love posted a 101.2 passer rating, 66.3% completion percentage, 23 TDs to just 6 interceptions in 15 games, and earned an 88.5 PFF overall grade (5th among all QBs). Caleb Williams finished with a 90.1 passer rating, 58.1% completion, 27 TDs to 7 interceptions in 17 games, and a 75.4 PFF grade (16th among QBs). Love outperformed Williams on passer rating, completion percentage, PFF grade, and TD:INT ratio — the majority of key efficiency metrics defined in the resolution criteria.