Bo Nix improved his passing yardage total (3,931 vs. 3,775 in 2024) and led the Broncos to a 12-win regular season and a Divisional Round playoff appearance, but his passer rating actually declined slightly (from 93.3 as a rookie to approximately 89.7 per StatMuse mid-season, with a final ESPN QBR of 58.3 ranked 15th). His TD count dropped from 29 to 25 and his PFF grade of 75.2 ranked only 17th among qualified QBs, well short of the 'top-12' threshold in the resolution criteria. Advanced metrics like ANY/A (6.02, 21st in the league) suggested his improvement was modest at best, and analysts noted his stats contained 'empty calories.' He did finish strong after a slow start, took the Broncos deep in the playoffs, and showed clutch traits, but the measurable 'big leap' in efficiency metrics did not materialize.

The Steelers did not start Mason Rudolph at quarterback in 2025 — Aaron Rodgers was the starter all season. Pittsburgh finished 10-7, won the AFC North, and made the playoffs. Rudolph only made one start (filling in for an injured Rodgers against the Bears in Week 12) and finished the season with just 310 passing yards and one start total, while the Steelers were 3-1 through the first four weeks alone.

Awaiting result — this take gets a grade once it resolves.